Toggle Menu
Greater Diversity News Homepage
  • Latest Jobs
    • Search Jobs
    • Send Advertisements/Jobs
    • Weekly PDF Editions
    • Subscribe to Print Edition
  • Books of Knowledge
    • Latest Books
    • Get Started: Reading Order
  • A Call to Colors
    • A Call to Colors Articles
    • About Civic Engagement Project
    • Civic Engagement Headlines
    • The Network for 2018
    • About Economic Equity
    • Economic Equity Headlines
    • GDN eNews Archives
  • Student Engagement
  • Subscribe
    • Subscribe to Print
    • Subscribe to eNews
    • eNews Archives
  • Virtual Events
  • Eastern NC
  • Sections/Archives
    • Latest Headlines
    • GDN eNews Archives
    • Books of Knowledge
    • Civic Engagement Headlines
    • Economic Equity Headlines
    • NAACP News
    • Print PDF Archives
    • All GDN Posts
  • Contact Us
    • General Questions
    • Send Advertisements
    • Contact GDN Sales
    • About GDN Products
    • Advertise
ACTC ACTC

National Civil Rights Groups File New Major Lawsuit Against Secretary Ben Carson and HUD

by GDN Shared Post May 9, 2018

 

Washington – A coalition of national fair housing groups today asked a federal court in Washington, D.C., to order the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) to reinstate a federal requirement that local and state governments address segregated housing patterns as a condition of receiving HUD funding.  The complaint, filed on behalf of The National Fair Housing Alliance (NFHA), Texas Appleseed, and Texas Low Income Housing Information Service (Texas Housers), alleges that HUD unlawfully suspended the requirement in January 2018, effectively removing civil rights oversight of as much as $5.5 billion per year until 2024 or later for almost 1,000 jurisdictions. In its place, HUD proposes that funding recipients revert to a fair housing planning process that HUD itself and the Government Accountability Office (GAO) have found is ineffective.

“With this lawsuit, the civil rights community is standing up to Secretary Ben Carson and fighting back against an egregious attempt to roll back a hard fought victory,” said Kristen Clarke, President and Executive Director of the Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights Under Law. “The 2015 Affirmatively Furthering Fair Housing Rule is a critical part of ongoing work to address structural racism and inequality today. Through this lawsuit, we are taking action to hold HUD accountable and ensure that HUD fulfills its mission of addressing ongoing racial segregation and housing discrimination which persist across the country today.”

The obligation to “affirmatively further fair housing” (AFFH) has applied to all HUD funding since the Fair Housing Act was passed in 1968. But it was not until July 2015 (47 years later) that HUD adopted the first effective set of federal regulations—known as the AFFH Rule—to guide the compliance efforts of local and state recipients of HUD’s block grant funds.  The AFFH Rule was adopted after years of study and consultation with stakeholders; HUD considered more than 1,000 formal comments before finalizing the Rule. Before HUD’s unlawful suspension of the AFFH Rule, advocates around the country had convinced many local governments to adopt strategies to eliminate housing discrimination and promote residential integration.

For some municipalities, the AFFH Rule would be delayed until at least 2024, affecting the lives and opportunities of millions of people. By suspending implementation of the Rule, local municipalities will receive government funds with no accountability.

In their lawsuit, the plaintiffs allege that HUD’s attempt to delay and dilute the AFFH Rule violates the Administrative Procedure Act, which sets out procedural and substantive requirements for the adoption and modification of federal regulations.  HUD failed to provide advance notice or opportunity to comment on the suspension and failed to articulate any plausible reason for the suspension.  Plaintiffs also allege that HUD’s action violates HUD’s own AFFH duty. The plaintiffs seek a court order requiring HUD to restart the implementation of the AFFH Rule immediately.

The plaintiffs are represented by the Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights Under Law, the law firm of Relman, Dane & Colfax PLLC, the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), the NAACP Legal Defense and Educational Fund, Inc. (LDF), the Poverty & Race Research Action Council (PRRAC), and Public Citizen Litigation Group.

Under HUD’s pre-2015 process, jurisdictions throughout the country routinely ignored problems of segregation and discrimination while continuing to collect HUD funds.  For instance, Muskegon County, Ohio, overlooked complaints over several decades from a predominately African-American neighborhood that was denied access to public water service, even as surrounding white neighborhoods were served.  Westchester County, New York, repeatedly certified its compliance with AFFH requirements even as it steered affordable housing developments into the most segregated neighborhoods in the county and permitted many white jurisdictions to resist affordable housing altogether.  And Houston, Texas, has repeatedly closed its eyes to unequal municipal drainage systems in which predominantly white communities are protected from storm surges with engineered drainage while communities of color are relegated to open ditches that predictably overflow into adjoining homes.

The AFFH Rule created a greatly improved system for HUD grantees, including local governments, states, territories, and public housing authorities, to fulfill their obligation to affirmatively further fair housing. The Rule’s required Assessment of Fair Housing (AFH) is an in-depth, holistic planning process that leverages data and robust community participation to inform the selection and prioritization of measures to overcome entrenched barriers to housing discrimination, residential integration, and access to opportunity.

Under the Rule, HUD grantees must conduct AFHs on a regular schedule by using a HUD-approved tool. HUD reviews the AFHs and either approves or rejects them. In stark contrast, the pre-2015 process did not require jurisdictions to submit their fair housing plans to HUD. In fact, the GAO’s analysis found that many jurisdictions did not even complete them. These jurisdictions were falsely certifying to HUD that they were fulfilling their obligation to affirmatively further fair housing when they were not doing so.

“For thirty years, NFHA has promoted the affirmatively furthering fair housing requirement of the Fair Housing Act. We have advocated to HUD to release an effective AFFH Rule, educated jurisdictions, fair housing groups and community-based organizations about the AFFH requirements, and implemented programs designed to further fair housing,” said Lisa Rice, President and CEO of NFHA. “Each day HUD holds up requiring jurisdictions to fully comply with the law is another day that millions of people are being denied fair housing opportunities. HUD’s action is a clear example of ‘justice delayed, justice denied’.”

The need for vigorous HUD oversight of its grantees’ compliance with fair housing laws is especially apparent in Texas. Plaintiffs Texas Appleseed and Texas Housers have a long track record of working to ensure the equitable use of federal housing and community development funds in the communities they serve, particularly in the aftermath of devastating hurricanes. The AFFH Rule is needed now more than ever as a bulwark against an unequal rebuilding process in the wake of Hurricane Harvey.

“We have spent over a decade working with state and local governments to provide understanding that segregation is not an accident—it is the product of decades of intentional government policy,” said Madison Sloan, Director of Texas Appleseed’s Disaster Recovery & Fair Housing Project. “Reversing segregation is critical—and not just for the communities that have been denied access to safe, decent neighborhoods through exclusion and disinvestment. It is research-based policy that benefits everyone. HUD’s unlawful suspension of the AFFH rule is a huge step backward in the movement to create equitable, inclusive communities.”

“Today, we challenge HUD’s outrageous disregard of a landmark civil rights law. Fifty years after our nation made a commitment to end housing discrimination, too many cities and states still use government funds in ways that deprive people of housing choices and maintain residential segregation,” said Christina Rosales, Communications Director of Texas Housers. “HUD painstakingly engaged in a multi-year public process to create a rule to put a stop to these illegal actions. Then in January, without due process and in violation of HUD’s sacred obligation, Secretary Carson suspended that rule and has forsaken civil rights enforcement. Since Secretary Carson has refused to do his job, we ask the courts to direct him to do so.”

“It took HUD almost 50 years to create an effective way to ‘affirmatively further’ fair housing—one that would actually eliminate the barriers that keep people of color trapped in segregated, low-opportunity neighborhoods,” said Sherrilyn Ifill, LDF President and Director-Counsel. “For Secretary Ben Carson and HUD to wipe away the rule just as it was beginning to take effect is shameful and contradicts what has been a fundamental principle of HUD’s mission. The court must order HUD to reinstate this critical rule and ensure that the agency does not take any arbitrary or illegal actions that threaten access to safe and affordable housing.”

“The communities we work with have looked to the AFFH Rule to realize the legacy of the civil rights movement, and to help fulfill their modern-day dreams of equality and racial inclusion. This administration has chosen to obstruct that progress. With the rule suspended, our tax dollars will continue to be used, in effect, to underwrite continuing segregation, lack of housing choice, and unequal opportunity throughout our country. We must restore the AFFH Rule and together move forward again,” said Megan Haberle, Deputy Director of PRRAC.

”What HUD has done in suspending the AFFH Rule can only be described as dereliction of its solemn duty to ensure that federal housing funds are distributed only to jurisdictions that comply with their civil rights obligations,” said Michael Allen, partner in the civil rights firm Relman, Dane & Colfax.  “Flouting the rule of law, HUD’s action signals to every jurisdiction in the country that there will be no consequence for civil rights violations, and that HUD has no interest in helping cities, counties and states to expand housing opportunities for their residents.”

“Domestic violence is a primary cause of homelessness for women and children. The AFFH rule played a crucial role in prompting communities to address the fair housing needs of domestic violence survivors, families with children, and others who have long been ignored. It needs to be reinstated,” said Sandra Park, Senior Staff Attorney with the ACLU’s Women’s Rights Project.

Read the full complaint, here.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Related Civic Engagement Headlines Articles

Similar Posts From Civic Engagement Headlines Category
Supreme Court Could Indirectly Empower Police to Silence Free Speech

Supreme Court Could Indirectly Empower Police to Silence Free Speech

January 3, 2018
Taking Aim at Corporate Impunity, Sanders’ Bill Would Send Big Pharma Execs Behind Opioid Crisis to Jai

Taking Aim at Corporate Impunity, Sanders’ Bill Would Send Big Pharma Execs Behind Opioid Crisis to Jai

April 18, 2018
Starbucks to Close All Stores Nationwide for Racial-Bias Education on May 29

Starbucks to Close All Stores Nationwide for Racial-Bias Education on May 29

April 18, 2018


Greater Diversity News Print Edition

Latest Jobs & Bids

Click here to send us your ad and get more information about advertising, or call 800-462-0738.

  1. Robeson Community College

    Administrative Assistant for Continuing Education and Workforce Development

  2. Robeson Community College

    Director of Fire and Rescue Training

  3. Smith-Rowe, LLC

    Cloverdale Avenue Pedestrian Improvements FB # 21177 project

  4. Sharpe Brothers

    NCDOT DG00516 Rockingham County Resurfacing project

  5. Johnston County Schools

    South Smithfield Elementary School Metal Roof Retrofit

  6. Johnston County Schools

    Addition to Archer Lodge Middle School

  7. Sharpe Brothers

    NCDOT C204617 Forsyth County Resurfacing project

  8. Piedmont Authority for Regional Transportation (PART)

    Repaint parking lot striping, bollards, railings and bus wash areas in the Coble Transportation Center and Administration building parking lots

  9. Jimmy R. Lynch & Sons, Inc.

    Winston-Salem (Forsyth County) Avalee, Martin Mill, and Lowery Lift Station Upgrades.

  10. North Carolina Department of Military Veteran Affairs

    Kinston State Veteran’s Home Roof Replacement

  11. Town of Smithfield, NC

    Police Officer I, Firefighter I, Public Works Director

  12. Edifice, Inc.

    Belmont Community Recreation Center in Belmont, NC

  13. Orange Water and Sewer Authority

    Chapel Hill North Pump Station Rehabilitation

  14. Yates Construction Co. Inc.

    City of Greensboro – Contract 2018-051B Davie Street Streetscape Storm and Water Improvements

  15. Smith-Rowe, LLC

    Durham County, Location Bridge 89 over Lick Creek Type of Work Structure

  16. Smith-Rowe, LLC

    Alexander County, Location, Bridge #291 on SR 1348 Over Duck Creek, Type of Work Grading, Drainage, Paving and Structure

  17. NC Department of Public Instruction / School Planning

    Campus Perimeter Security Project (SCO ID# 17-16723-01A) at the Eastern NC School for the Deaf in Wilson, NC

  18. Baker Mechanical, Inc.

    Seeking Minority Prices for work relating to HVAC

  19. Wilmington Housing Authority

    Maintenance Supervisor and Housing Choice Voucher Inspections Coordinator

  20. Robeson Community College

    Admissions Specialist

  21. A. R. Chesson Construction Company

    Maintenance Garage for Eastern NC School for the Deaf

  22. Vecellio & Grogan, Inc.

    NCDOT US70 Business to Neuse River Bridge w/Interchanges at SR-1501 & SR-1919 Project in Johnston Co., NC

  23. Jacksonville Mechanical, Inc.

    Decatur Pump Station Abandonment, Jacksonville, NC

  24. Branch Builds, Inc.

    Minority, Women, and Disadvantaged Business Enterprises for the upcoming bid for Olympic HS, Harding HS, and South Meck HS CTE Renovations located in Charlotte, NC

  25. Branch Builds, Inc.

    Olympic HS, Harding HS, and South Meck HS CTE Renovations located in Charlotte, NC

  26. All Hands Cleaning, LLC

    We Clean Anything Residential or Commercial 

  27. Bar Construction Co., Inc.

    Ballfield Infield Renovations at Valley Springs Park in Durham, NC

  28. Bar Construction Co., Inc.

    Eastern Alamance High School Additions & Renovations in Mebane, NC

  29. Bar Construction Co., Inc.

    Go Triangle Bus Stops Construction (Group A) in Durham, NC

  30. Bar Construction Co., Inc.

    Walter M. Williams High School Electrical Service Relocation in Burlington, NC

  31. Bar Construction Co., Inc.

    Graham High School in Graham, NC

  32. Bar Construction Co., Inc.

    Western Alamance High School Additions & Renovations in Burlington, NC

  33. Lomax Construction, Inc.

    Walter M. Williams High School Bond Project, Burlington, NC

  34. Lomax Construction, Inc.

    Eastern Alamance High School, Burlington, NC

  35. Southeastern Community College

    Carpentry, Electrical, General Contractor, Outboard Engine Maintenance PLC, Plumbing, 3D Printing, Real Estate, Roofing

  36. Southeastern Community College

    Chief Operating Office/VP Of Administrative Services Director, Small Business Center Grounds Maintenance Worker

  37. Jimmy R. Lynch & Sons, Inc.

    Winston-Salem (Forsyth County) Access Road at Idols Road Lift Station.

  38. North Carolina Department of Public Safety

    Johnston County out for bid: C-TBD Johnston CI Boiler and Water Heater Replacement

  39. City of Statesville, NC

    Recreation & Parks Department Statesville Fitness & Activity Center: Facility Manager

  40. State Utility Contractors, Inc.

    Rockfish Creek Water Reclamation Facility Screening Improvements project located in Fayetteville, NC

  41. Pender County Schools

    Request for Proposals for Insurance Services

  42. Haren Construction Company, Inc.

    Fayetteville, NC – Rockfish Creek WRF Screening Improvements Project

  43. City of Asheboro

    Chemical Bids For City of Asheboro Water/Wastewater Treatment Plants

  44. Barnhill Contracting Company

    Town of Sunset Beach 2021 Street Resurfacing 8641Linear Footage Of City Streets

  45. H.M. Kern Corporation

    Graham HS Renovations project

  46. H.M. Kern Corporation

    Asheboro HS Phase 3 Renovation project

  47. H.M. Kern Corporation

    NC A&T Merrick Hall Roof Replacement project

  48. CNS Builders, Inc.

    Gas Station Convenient Store Greensboro, NC

  49. Barnhill Contracting Company

    Heavy Highway Division Contract ID:  C204359

  50. North Carolina Department of Public Safety

    DART Cherry Mold Abatement and HVAC Repairs

  51. Global Process Automation, LLC (Wilmington, NC)

    Sr. Automation Engineer

  52. New Atlantic Contracting, Inc.

    Asheboro High School Renovations – Phase 3, 1221 South Park Street, Asheboro, North Carolina 27203

  53. NHM Constructors, LLC

    03/09/21: DN00493 Haywood-Bridge No. 401 over Little East Fork Pigeon River on SR 1236 (Brown Hollow Rd) and DN00495 at Bridge No. 276 over Burnett Creek on SR 1104 (Burnett Cove Rd)

  54. University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill

    Mitchell-Dey Electrical Upgrades SCO Project # 17-18102-01

  55. City of Sanford

    Selection, Design and Implementation of a File Retrieval And Archival System

  56. Town of Greenevers

    USDA – Greenevers Street Improvements, Contract No. 21 – 2021 Street Improvements

  57. Town of Ayden

    2020 Sanitary Sewer Improvements Contract No. 5 – NC 102 East Sanitary Sewer Extension

  58. Beco, Inc.

    Walter M. Williams High School Electrical Service Relocation

  59. Barnhill Contracting Company

    Town of Rose Hill Street Resurfacing FY 20-21 #2, NCDOT Onslow County Resurfacing & Pavement Preservation and NCDOT Lenoir County Milling, Strengthening, Resurfacing, & Shoulder Reconstruction Projects

  60. Barnhill Contracting Company

    NCDOT Contract: #DA00428 Pasquotank County – Drainage, Base, Paving & Resurfacing at US 17/NC 158 and Main St Extended

  61. Balfour Beatty Construction

    New Chatham County – Emergency Operations and Communications Center in Pittsboro, NC

  62. Robeson Community College

    Financial Aid Specialist

  63. City of Statesville, NC

    Public Works Department Stormwater Division: Skilled Laborer, Public Utilities Department Water/Sewer Maintenance Division: Commercial Driver

  64. H.M. Kern Corporation

    Lee Co. Government Center Re-Roof project

  65. H.M. Kern Corporation

    Raleigh PD HVAC Replacement project

  66. Cumberland County Schools

    South View Middle School Phase 2 Classroom HVAC Upgrade.

  67. North Carolina Department of Transportation

    (C204359) Johnston; (C204202) Henderson ; (C204521) Pitt; (C204618) Vance; (C204610) Person

  68. NC Department of Public Instruction / School Planning

    Woodard Hall Toilet Renovations project (SCO ID# 20-22543-01) at the Eastern NC School for the Deaf in Wilson, NC

  69. Robersonville Housing Authority

    Comprehensive Purchasing Consortium (CPC) Carolinas Council of Housing Redevelopment & Codes Officials, Inc.

  70. UNC Charlotte

    Redesign of Modifications to J.W. Clay Blvd. & Robert D. Snyder Rd. project

  71. North Carolina State Ports Authority

    C-1520 Radio Communications Tower and Civil Works, North Carolina State Ports Authority, Port of Wilmington and Port of Morehead City, NCSPA Contract No. C-1520.

  72. North Carolina State Ports Authority

    Security Generator Replacement – MHC, Port of Morehead City, NCSPA Contract No. C-1535(M)

  73. Turner Murphy Company, Inc.

    City of Bishopville WWTP Sludge Dewatering & Clarifier Upgrades

  74. Turner Murphy Company, Inc.

    Batesburg-Leesville WWTP Aerator Replacement Project

  75. Piedmont Triad Airport Authority

    Runway 5R-23L Rehabilitation Project, Construction Phase 4


tetsaro
actc video
Banner

  • Refund Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Job Posting
  • GDN eNews Subscription for Economic Equity Updates

Designed by Raibach Inc.

© 2017 Copyright Greater Diversity News. All Rights reserved.

  Close Window

Loading, Please Wait!

This may take a second or two. Loading
SUBSCRIBE
Processing...
Thank you! Your subscription has been confirmed. You'll hear from us soon.
Subscribe to Get Updates and the Latest Headlines
Email updates sent weekly on Voter Engagement, Economic Equity, and weekly Job Postings.
ErrorHere
Powered By Campaign Monitor